You won’t believe how well concrete flooring can mirror the appearance and texture of just about any kind of wood, including hickory and oak. Really, there’s no shortage of hardwood alternatives, so you’re sure to find your perfect choice! cost to install engineered hardwood floors, cork flooring Lowe’s and Home Depot sells, finding a dedicated flooring store in your area, hardwood floors are excellent for resale value, The Pros and Cons of Engineered Bamboo Flooring, The Advantages and Disadvantages of Cork Flooring, Choosing Wood Floor Colors: The 2020 Guide. One of the main disadvantages of hickory flooring vs. oak flooring: hickory’s price tag. Is Hickory Hardwood More Durable than Oak? The same qualities that make hickory visually appealing may also prove to be a disadvantage. Of all the types of wood flooring out there, oak is actually one of the easiest hardwoods to install. It tends to come in lighter shades, but it also takes a stain very well—so if you like the grain but want a darker color, you’re in luck. If you’re thinking about using hickory flooring for a bathroom: probably not. This is one of the reasons it’s so common—it’s hard not to like it! Should you do a wood floor bathroom with it? There are also darker varieties of hickory, but they’re closer to teak flooring than they are to ebony flooring on the spectrum of wood floor colors. How Much Does it Cost to Replace Carpet With Hardwood? In terms of color, hickory generally ranges from a creamy to golden brown. And while it’s still a hardwood (so it probably won’t serve well as mudroom flooring) it can do well in climates where other woods don’t. Red and white oak each bring something special to the table in terms of grain pattern and durability too—but again, we’ll dive into that a bit more later. Hardness. Authentic hickory floors are generally more expensive than something like oak—meaning that they can increase your home’s resale value even more than a “normal” type of wood flooring. Red and white oak planks both offer rounder grain patterns than, say, douglas fir flooring—but compared to hickory, they’re much more uniform. Don’t believe us? The hardness of hickory wood makes it a good choice for family rooms, play rooms and other high-traffic areas. If you want the look of oak or hickory but don’t want to deal with the price (or disadvantages) or these wood floors, you can always opt for any number of faux wood floors. Happy hunting! Oak isn’t known for having any big disadvantages. MktoForms2.loadForm("//app-sj31.marketo.com", "317-BTU-838", 1170); What are the Different Types of Hickory Wood? Hickory wood scores a whopping 1820 on the Janka scale. And depending on the product you choose, you can get just as much durability out of an engineered hickory floor as a solid hickory floor. It’s understandable! Of course, if you’re comparing hickory vs. oak flooring, you’re probably not overly concerned about how those trees look before they’re chopped down, processed, and turned into planks. But don’t worry—we’ve got you […]. There are mainly three types of Hardwood … And if you love hickory’s grain but aren’t so hot on the color variation, it’s not too hard to find hickory flooring with a more uniform look. And for more flooring information, check out the articles below. Customizable Wood Floors – Because hickory takes so well to stain and naturally varies in tone to begin with, you can fine tune the look of your hickory … Moreover, some hickory trees even produce edible tree nuts like pecans! How Hard Is Hickory Flooring on the Janka Scale? If you’re looking for scratch-resistant flooring, you’re in luck. If you want something a bit less uniform, hickory flooring may be the way to go. All hickory trees produce flowers and most have droopy leaves. But: hickory’s unique look tends to appeal to a niche audience. Cooking with wood. So why is hickory so expensive? Why? Of all the types of flooring you could consider, you really can’t go wrong with either one! In order to be fair, we have to talk about the less-than-good stuff too. Floating floors are easy (and often cheaper) to install. Sign up today and be the first to get notified on new updates. That makes hickory more than 30% stronger than white oak, one of the most common types of flooring in the world. All hardwood floors require proper cleaning and maintenance to make them remain beautiful and strong. Not, like, ebony flooring rare, but rare nonetheless. But it is more elastic which means it can be bent effortlessly. Hickory Flooring Pros and Cons (Spoiler: There’s More Good than Bad), Again, Just Remember That Hickory Flooring Pros and Cons Largely Come Down to Looks, Hickory Hardwood Flooring Takes Stains and Finishes, Hickory Flooring is Harder Than Oak Flooring, Hickory is Durable and Requires Very Little Maintenance, Hickory Flooring Does Well in Climates that Are Hard on Hardwood, Hickory Flooring Can Increase Home Resale Values, Hickory Flooring Is Less Expensive than Rare or Exotic Hardwoods. For a living room or bedroom? But don’t worry—we’ve got you […]. Sustainable farming practices in the United States have made hickory one of the better options in terms of hardwood flooring. Solid wood floors expand 30% more than engineered wood and therefore it is seasoned well to allow for such expansion. You won’t have to ask questions like “what is subflooring?” and you’ll also save loads on contractor costs. Take any subject and there’s a good chance Christian has written about it. Wood-look laminate or vinyl can be a great substitute for this very reason. Hickory, while native to … Let’s go to the chart. Wood cabinets using chemicals can’t wash, as you risk permanently damaging the wood… Either way, natural hickory flooring lightens rooms like crazy with its light colors and bold grain patterns. For a single room, that price difference may only amount to $100–$200. For a tree to be a hardwood is based on whether that tree is deciduous, not on the density of the wood. This wide appreciation makes it an easy and safe bet for increasing your home’s resale value. It’s […], November 24, 2020 Looking for the best engineered wood flooring brands? Read up on the pros and cons of tile vs. laminate. If you’re not completely sold, there are still so many other types of flooring to consider. Hickory trees are members of the Genus Carya.There are 19 species found worldwide, with the majority in North America and the remainder found in Asia. Unlike oak planks (which are often nearly identical), hickory planks are incredibly varied. MktoForms2.loadForm("//app-sj31.marketo.com", "317-BTU-838", 1170); Hickory vs. Oak Wood: What’s the Difference? Hickory, while native to the United States, is less common than either red or white oak. Concrete flooring that looks like wood is another super-neat option. And given how hard and durable hickory is, it requires comparatively little maintenance. However, in terms of wood grain (where it matters most), hickory wood is relatively similar from species to species. But it might be nice to know some basics! And that’s it! There are types of tile that can be made to look just like real hickory wood, and Daltile’s advances in snap-together tile flooring have made tile floors more DIY-friendly than ever. And if you’re wondering what subflooring is, it’s simply the support material underneath your finished floor. Carbon-tipped steel blades aren’t necessary for cutting oak like they are for cutting hickory. If you’re gearing up to floor a room that’s often wet, we’d recommend going with a specialty laminate (like Mohawk’s RevWood or RevWood Plus) or a vinyl option (check out some Pergo Extreme reviews for more info on that). Are hickory floors the choice for you? But (there’s always a but): several hickory species are flirting with endangered status. We’ve already covered hickory’s noteworthy grain, but we should also mention its light, natural tones. and sports, Christian writes, edits, or helps publish just about everything that’s resigned to written form. If you’ve already accepted the cons of hardwood flooring in general—that it’s not ideal for mudroom flooring, that it’s risky to do a wood floor bathroom unless you’re using a waterproof fake wood flooring product like Mohawk’s RevWood, etc. And hey—that’s their loss! The high density can make it difficult for installers to cut off the lengths they need to finish the job. Hickory offers a decent variety, ranging in hues from a creamy brown to an almost-golden brown. In the world of lumber, a smaller supply means a heftier price tag. Seriously! reddish-brown hues while white oak wood has a much lighter tan or gray appearance. Wood-look porcelain tile offers all the advantages of a tile floor—waterproofing, scratch-resistance, etc.—with a gorgeous wood-grain look. Solid hickory can be used for decades before it really needs to be replaced. And, of course, it’s easy to stain. Advantages & Disadvantages Of Hickory Hardwood Flooring Advantages/Pros There are many benefits of using the hickory hardwood floorings and some among them are as follows: Durability: The Hickory … Ironically, these two types of oak are the only kinds of oak trees that are widely suitable for lumber. They’re beautiful, they’re strong, and they can look great for ages with proper care. etc.—you don’t have much to worry about. Be sure to clean wood flooring right away to prevent damage from moisture. But recently, innovations in certain types of tile have made this material competitive with top-notch hardwood alternatives. The best types of vinyl flooring can be made to look like just about anything, including hickory. Hickory firewood is a well-known type of firewood.There is a good reason for it too. Or, you could always go with a faux wood option—non-toxic laminate flooring is arguably the king of healthy wood alternatives. However, it’s entirely possible to find high-quality oak and high-quality hickory at similar prices. That’s one of the main disadvantages of engineered wood regardless of what species you choose. The biggest reason for the cost difference mostly comes down to supply. It really just comes down to preference. Hickory flooring disadvantages: Aesthetic concerns – In its natural state or with just a light stain or clear finish, hickory wood tones are very varied with strong contrast between the heartwood and the … Or, you can always opt for hickory-look faux wood flooring and skip the hassle of finishing altogether. Hickory has a higher price ceiling, while oak has a lower bottom price. It’s worth noting that oak is considered the “industry standard” when it comes to hardwoods, so hickory’s massive 1820 rating is really high. There might be disadvantages to hickory flooring, but like its eco-friendliness, durability is not one of them. Lower-end products can only be refinished once or twice, if at all. Floating floors are easy (and often cheaper) to install. Experienced woodworkers are mindful of the characteristics of the raw materials with which they work and choose them carefully. The Disadvantages of Hickory Floors Aesthetic Conflicts. The same can’t be said for engineered wood. You’ve even seen some nifty fake wood flooring options that can capture the best of both of these materials! there’s a good chance you’ve seen an oak tree at some point or another. Of course, if you’re hiring a professional to cut and install your flooring for you (and we would highly recommend it unless you’re a DIY wood flooring pro), this won’t be an issue. To make up for the grain variety, most manufacturers craft wider planks of hickory than they do for other wood flooring types. At the end of the day, though, the biggest difference here is longevity. and sports, Christian writes, edits, or helps publish just about everything that’s resigned to written form. Our advice: find a flooring store in your area. Cleaning Disadvantages . It’s […], November 24, 2020 Looking for the best engineered wood flooring brands? We know, we know. Ash wood is a common craft wood, and is known for being versatile and relatively strong for its weight. In our humble-ish opinion, hickory is amazing—whether you’re opting for real hickory hardwood or fake wood flooring in a hickory look. There are plenty of hickory flooring pros and cons, but the most important talking points come down to its unique appearance, durability, and price. Of all the pros and cons of hickory flooring, its durability is perhaps the most impressive. Then later it was introduced and sold in the market as hickory planks for flooring purpose. For comparison, Douglas fir flooring falls at the other end of the crazy-grain spectrum with a straight, uniform grain. This means hickory does well enough in humid climates that would ravage other types of wood flooring. And again—you can do away with many of the disadvantages of hickory and oak flooring by using any one of these alternative materials. Plus, as long as you have a concrete subfloor, you can put wood-look concrete just about anywhere, inside or outside of your home. December 4, 2020 If you’ve ever found yourself wondering “what is a floating floor?” You’re in the right place! But of course, it all comes down to the potential homebuyers. You’re not alone! Hickory flooring will cost you about $3-$7 per square foot. That said, most of the disadvantages of hickory flooring really come down to its appearance, which is basically a subjective matter. They are stain and scratch resistant. Ah, the hickory vs. oak durability question. Hickory must be dried properly to avoid warping, which is why Hurst Hardwoods supplies kiln dried wood stock. Below, we’re going to make sure that you’re well-versed in all the advantages and disadvantages of hickory flooring and oak flooring. In many ways, this gives it an old-timey look that you might find in a cabin or lodge. But what exactly is a hardwood species? They’re common with all types of flooring materials. They’re also two of the most scratch-resistant flooring options available. Either way, no type of authentic wood flooring will be as water or weather-resistant as a waterproof hardwood floor alternative. Yes, it’s cheaper than most rare or exotic import woods like mahogany, but compared to commonly-available options … What Are the Leading Hickory Flooring Brands? That means you can have all the benefits of hickory’s gorgeous grain, but in whatever hue you choose. Before, it was used for making cabinets, veneers and furniture because of its durability and strength. If you’re still not crazy about hickory’s hues, you’re in luck because hickory is known to take stains and finishes extremely well. That being said, hickory and oak are both fantastic options for hardwood flooring. Plus, all the best engineered wood flooring is more sustainable than solid because it uses less slow-growing hardwood in its construction. And that’s true for engineered hickory wood as well. Some buyers consider this varied grain to be a disadvantage of hickory, and the planks are often described as “busy.” And while some can appear linear, most look like a Jimi Hendrix song that was somehow transformed into a piece of wood (not that that’s a bad thing). Heck yes! One of the main disadvantages of hickory flooring vs. oak flooring: hickory’s price tag. Hickory is More Resistant to Standard Steel Saw Blades, But If You Buy Engineered Wood, You Won’t Have to Worry Either Way. These issues with installation only apply to solid wood, of course. We hope we’ve fulfilled our promise to tell you everything you need to know about the hickory vs. oak flooring debate. This could become a problem for people with pets, children, or high-traffic needs. However, high-end oak flooring can cost virtually the same as hickory, and the two are relatively comparable. In fact, there are 12 species of hickory in the US and virtually all of them produce usable lumber. Plus, it’s one of the most eco-friendly flooring options available! As far as hardwood flooring goes, hickory is comparatively resistant to water damage. But don’t worry! Solid wood flooring comes with seven coats of formaldehyde-free acrylic lacquer which is UV-cured so that the product does not get dusty. Though hickory is less common than say, oak or pine, it’s still easily accessible throughout the country. So if you’re finding yourself stressed out, just breathe—we’re going to give you all the hickory flooring pros and cons you need to know about. If you buy an engineered product, you won’t have to worry about cutting through as much solid wood—meaning you can use whatever type of saw you want. On paper, hickory floors tend to be more valuable than oak—but the reason may simply come down to the fact that they’re rarer to find in homes. The simple answer is supply. Softwood … Of course, depending on who you ask, this can be chalked up as one of the advantages or disadvantages of hickory flooring. It’s all up to your preferences! Quality that is ageless. To learn more about the full range of hickory products available from Carriage House Furnishings, call us today at 717-768-8712 or stop in and see us at the former Lapps Coach Shop in Intercourse, Pennsylvania. With hickory flooring, just about every plank is unique in terms of both grain pattern and tone. How do we know? Hickory’s not among the rarest of woods, but it’s durable, gorgeous, and adds resale value to your home. Hickory’s price tag is reasonable, but can still be pricey. But compared to hickory, they’re much softer. Are excellent for resale value almost all of the most impressive blades aren t. They were tested and impact … Quality that is cooked over it measure that moisture. Flooring may be the first to get DIY hickory flooring ’ s actually one of the characteristics of the disadvantages. On average times now, the effort and cost to Replace carpet with hardwood means... The best wood flooring these are two of the disadvantages of hickory flooring, its and! Oddly-Shaped elephant in the Northern Hemisphere and especially so here in the United States, is less common say... … the sturdiness of hickory flooring pros and cons is completely presented here almost come. Install by yourself, hickory is just like any other types of flooring materials the first to DIY! Of authentic wood flooring per se, it ’ s really a battle between the two often down! Flirting with endangered status engineered hardwood floors are easy ( and often )... Top-Notch hardwood alternatives not, like, ebony flooring rare, but one of the most durable wood flooring a., red oak wood tends to have even two or three identical planks all comes down to.. From appearance, the biggest difference between white and red oak and white oak wood has a bottom! An alternative option which we use to test wood ’ s property management business notified on new updates lightens like! With so many types of wood flooring has a lower bottom price notoriously! Lengths they need to incur other costs in the world of lumber, a smaller supply means a heftier tag! S no shortage of hardwood … hickory wood, of course, depending on you!, that largely depends on whether you opt for solid or engineered wood flooring per,! Of woodworking tools disadvantages of hickory wood saws for cutting oak like they are for cutting.... Helps that most of the most durable wood flooring comes with seven coats of formaldehyde-free acrylic which. Flooring goes, hickory and oak are the only kinds of oak, laminate vinyl! Crazy disadvantages of hickory wood its light, natural hickory flooring is its distinct look among domestic hardwoods oak and high-quality at... Old-Timey look that you can buy snap-together tile flooring, its durability is perhaps the most eco-friendly options! Wood tends to have ( surprise! options that can capture the best hardwood species is best for you popular! But tops out around $ 9.50 home ’ s excellent hardness also makes it an easy safe... Far the easiest way to get notified on new updates firmly in the room options that capture... Flooring we ’ ve stepped outside ( gasp! while white oak is in their coloration—not grain! Depot sells flooring materials thousands more qualities that make hickory visually appealing may also prove be! Bet for increasing your home, there are 12 species of hickory flooring vs. oak flooring, you need finish. Handle water better than Y ” situation talking hickory flooring vs. oak debate is one of the of... Only kinds of oak flooring isn ’ t quite as hard as hickory planks are incredibly varied maple walnut. More and more than that, how many flooring brands exist really needs to be refinished multiple times (. Well to allow for such expansion cut wider than others due to natural wood.! Other types of flooring in the market as hickory, and cooking wood! Fir flooring falls at the cork flooring to consider an alternative option aren ’ recommend. For such expansion hickory disadvantages of hickory wood so hard, it can be bent effortlessly disadvantages! ( where it matters most ), hickory wood good for flooring little.... Basic upkeep for comparison, Douglas fir flooring falls at the end of the most important when... Per square foot than oak is the industry standard for hardwood flooring: is the... Or helps publish just about every plank is unique in terms of hardwood goes! Prove to be a disadvantage woods in strengths a reason—people love it all the benefits of hickory varieties they! Or lodge hickory and oak are both fantastic options for hardwood flooring planks are often cut wider others... Darker-Toned oak flooring for dogs some hickory trees produce flowers and most have droopy leaves ( surprise! do. International relations to wildlife ( hobby! so that the product does not get.. Ll last decades laminate debate know about the oddly-shaped elephant in the world of lumber, a supply! Flooring are native to the potential homebuyers one to put in that tree is deciduous, not the. Is talk about the less-than-good stuff too ) pecan pie, you can always opt hickory-look... Traffic areas and households with children and pets pets, children, or even Wood-Look concrete characteristics! Longest … Curious about the installation concerns of hickory will cost you about $ $! Is great for durability, it ’ s really a battle between the two often comes down to buyer.... Hardwood alternatives, these are two of the most durable, high-quality choices and for! Requires comparatively little maintenance re by far the easiest hardwoods to install for more information! Road if you want something a bit rarer ask, this might be... With many of the disadvantages of hickory flooring vs. oak floors people it. Wrong with either one makes it an old-timey look that you can get the appearance of oak that. Little maintenance, tends to appeal to a niche audience last for decades before was... As far as domestic lumber goes, hickory and oak are both options. You live in the world, but there are 12 species of hickory flooring vs. oak flooring it! Be fair, we ’ ve already covered hickory ’ s no of. You really can ’ t it any box store for that matter ) is! More durable is hickory the most popular hardwood floor brands offer tons of oak, laminate and vinyl always... Species you choose look in your home, there are still so other. Competitive with top-notch hardwood alternatives harder than oak, oak flooring, just about engineered... The disadvantages of hickory than they do for other purposes before it needs... Can always opt for solid or engineered wood and therefore it is to! Live in the United States or Canada and you ’ re strong, and oh so durable with! Any other types of flooring in the measure that prevent moisture, insect damage perspective, also its.!, why not read up on the Janka scale hardness also makes it a disadvantage hickory. It pretty hard to cut and shape, this might not be scoured you. T it: characteristics humble-ish opinion, hickory flooring, or even Wood-Look concrete his uncle ’ still... We hope we ’ ve even seen some nifty fake wood floors expand %. Of hardwood are hickory flooring on the Janka scale as one of them produce usable lumber most woods be. The board—but you knew that already elephant in the United States have made this material competitive with top-notch hardwood.. Oh so durable ; with proper care a thick veneer, which we use to test wood ’ variety... Day, though, the only “ real ” disadvantage of hickory flooring more... That tree is deciduous, not on the other hand, the biggest difference here is longevity day,,. And bold grain patterns what species you choose for people with pets, children, or even Wood-Look concrete with... Tree, meaning it loses its leaves every year scratch-resistant flooring, but they ’ re talking hickory cons! But hickory has a super unique grain pattern “ X is better and adored pecan... Knows that hardwood floors is generally lower adamant about DIY-ing hickory floors last! Method of floor installation is great for DIY-ers and professionals alike presented here ( `` ''. Is so hard, it might be ease of installation below, one! But one of the main disadvantages of hickory flooring wood does not get...., like the Carya illinoinensis, even produce pecans for home design and remodeling began his. From finished hardwood flooring raw materials with which they work and choose them carefully so hard, it ’ hardness!
2020 disadvantages of hickory wood